Gold Mines in Freefall: How Low Will Newmont, Franco Nevada, and Agnico Go?
#Global Markets

Gold Mines in Freefall: How Low Will Newmont, Franco Nevada, and Agnico Go?

Author

Arcan Askin

The Gold Mine Dilemma: Rising Costs and Investor Skepticism Shake Even the Best

Despite posting impressive third-quarter results, gold mining giants Newmont, Franco-Nevada, and Agnico Eagle have seen their stock prices tumble. Newmont beat earnings expectations with a $1.71 per share profit, Franco-Nevada celebrated record revenues and a debt-free balance sheet, and Agnico Eagle reported record production. So why the steep decline? Exploding operational costs are eroding profit margins while historical mismanagement has left investor trust hanging by a thread. Technical indicators are also flashing warning signs.

The Rising Cost Tsunami: Cannibalizing Profits

The mining industry is grappling with surging costs that are devouring profits as gold prices climb to record highs. Between 2020 and 2023, All-In Sustaining Costs (AISC) surged nearly 30%, reaching an average of $1,350 per ounce. Energy expenses, which can comprise 20% to 30% of operating costs, have skyrocketed 35%. As these costs continue to mount, profit margins shrink, casting a shadow over the positive aspects of record gold prices.

Historical Missteps: Billions in Shareholder Value Vanished

Historical mismanagement stands as a significant hurdle, eroding investor faith considerably. Over the boom years, these mining companies squandered billions in shareholder value through disastrous acquisitions and poor investment choices. From 2003 to 2012 alone, approximately $500 billion went up in smoke due to poor M&A decisions. This pattern of capital destruction has nurtured deep skepticism among investors, particularly institutional ones, making them hesitant to re-engage despite high gold prices.

Gold-Silver Ratio: The Underestimated Signal

The Gold-Silver Ratio provides another dimension to the looming correction. Historically, secular bull markets in precious metals wind down when the ratio approaches 15:1, yet the current ratio hovers above 80:1. This suggests gold is exceedingly strong relative to silver, indicating the bull market might not yet be in its twilight, but the ratio’s implications weigh heavily on mining stock valuations more than high gold prices alone.

FAQ

Why are gold mining stocks falling despite high gold prices?

Stocks are tumbling due to skyrocketing costs of energy, labor, and regulatory compliance that chew into profit margins. Moreover, past management blunders have considerably eroded investor trust, compounding these challenges.

Are gold mines a good investment?

Gold mines can yield high returns in certain market stages but come with significant risks akin to any investment opportunity. Besides operational and managerial risks, they are highly contingent on gold price trajectories. The current underperformance underscores this complexity. We analyze 22 individual stocks and ETFs in gold, silver, copper, and Bitcoin mining sectors, providing daily access to trading zones and portfolio management insights. Learn more here.

Which gold mining stocks have seen the steepest declines?

During the recent correction on October 21, 2025, Newmont (-9.1%), Agnico Eagle (-8.7%), and Franco-Nevada (-5.1%) emerged as significant losers. Others, like Kinross Gold and Alamos Gold, faced even larger double-digit setbacks.

Author

Arcan Askin

Headlines

Consent was never given.

You need to first accept consent to see this content from TradingView.