The Power of Social Media: How One Post Can Spark Panic

The Power of Social Media: How One Post Can Spark Panic

Author

Carlo Schmid

Panic, Social Media, and Financial Crises: A Perfect Storm

It's Friday evening. You're sprawled comfortably on your Rolf Benz sofa, phone in hand, surfing through social media. Suddenly, a post flashes before your eyes: "Warning: Your Bank Is Going Insolvent!" No sooner do you register this information, your phone buzzes with a WhatsApp message from your best friend: "Have you seen what's happening with the bank?" What does this prompt in you? Panic? Fear? Or do you remain calm and composed, eager to check the facts yourself?

If you landed on the last response, congratulations! You're among the rare few who don't easily succumb to social media pressure. For most people, however, such posts ignite a quick panic response, which poses a huge problem in the financial world.

The Silicon Valley Bank Collapse: A 48-Hour Debacle

Back in March 2023, this scenario unfurled in real-time when Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) experienced a digital-age bank run. News had surfaced that the bank suffered a staggering $1.8 billion loss and was scrambling for fresh capital. Within the tightly-knit tech and startup community, this news spread like wildfire—through social media, chats, and phone calls. Suddenly, the question on everyone's lips was: Is our money safe?

Within just a single day, customers withdrew $40 billion from their accounts. Two days later, the writing was on the wall; SVB was unable to meet its commitments and was essentially bankrupt—demonstrating how a bank run unfolds in a digital landscape.

The crisis was markedly exacerbated by the role of social media which accelerated the panic. Tweets and WhatsApp messages sufficed to send countless individuals into a state of fright. Online warnings urged investors to withdraw funds from SVB, and customers did just that, amplifying the vicious cycle. What started as speculative online chatter turned into a relentless chain reaction, leaving the bank insolvent within a mere 48 hours.

Explaining the Panic Reaction

This behavior follows well-documented psychological patterns. Financial psychology identifies several reasons why people act irrationally during crises. The Prospect Theory, for instance, explains how uncertainties regarding gains or losses evoke intense fears of loss.

The dread of potential loss often drives individuals to make rash, hasty decisions. Clients or investors in such scenarios tend to withdraw funds swiftly—even when facts don't warrant such action. Why? Because losses psychologically inflict more pain than gains elicit pleasure. Faced with threatened losses, individuals resort to drastic measures to preemptively avert losses, heeding their instincts instead of their assessments—as was the case with SVB, where mass withdrawals happened at breakneck speed.

Loss of Control

In SVB's situation, this behavior instigated a classic chain reaction: Initial investors, spurred by posts on X and WhatsApp, pulled their funds. Their actions were visible online, intensifying the panic and persuading more customers to act swiftly. Within two days, so much capital had been yanked that the bank became insolvent. The trigger wasn’t rational concern by all customers but rather the collective fear of imagined losses that prompted extreme actions.

Enter FOMO, or "Fear of Missing Out". For investors, this fear means falling behind, prompting overtrading in a bid to not be the last to react and face losses alone. But acting in haste isn't the only peril; stubbornly holding on to poor investments due to misplaced convictions can be costly too.

Attachment Breeds Blindness

We're all familiar with the saying: "Love makes us blind." The wisdom behind this nugget applies equally in the world of investments: "Don't marry your bags". Clinging to investments just because of past performance is as risky as swiftly selling in panic. Sometimes, it's just as important to know when it's time to let go.

The Halo Effect leads investors to irrationally attribute positive characteristics to their thriving investments. A booming Spotify stock? Sky-high potential! I've already gained fivefold? I'll hold out for the next doubling! This flawed perception means investors linger longer than they should—eventually squandering temporary gains.

In the volatile crypto industry, this caution is epitomized by "Don't marry your bags". Emotional bonds with our positions cloud rational judgment during both highs and lows. The outcome? We sell too late, missing the chance to capitalize on gains or minimize losses when the tide turns.

A Call for Emotional Detachment

The influence of emotions, social media, and human psychology on financial decision-making is undeniable. The antidote? Emotional detachment. To ensure long-term investing success and yields, one must block out the social media noise and focus on personal strategies—think technical analysis. Steering clear of emotional trading empowers investors to act rationally and strategically, clearing the way for sound investment decisions.

Author

Carlo Schmid

Headlines

Consent was never given.

You need to first accept consent to see this content from TradingView.